Trump administration grants ICE access to Medicaid records in sweeping data-sharing agreement
The Trump administration authorized ICE to access personal data (names, addresses, Social Security numbers, etc.) of over 79 million Medicaid recipients, aiming to identify and deport undocumented immigrants.
Privacy advocates and Democratic lawmakers warn this could deter vulnerable populations from seeking medical care, while supporters argue it prevents misuse of taxpayer-funded benefits. Legal challenges are underway, with 20 states suing over privacy violations.
CMS staff and attorneys raised objections, citing ongoing litigation, but the agreement proceeded. Critics accuse the administration of turning health care administrators into immigration enforcers.
ICE can only access records on weekdays until September 9 without direct downloads, but critics argue the policy undermines trust in public health programs, especially in states offering Medicaid to some noncitizens.
The move aligns with the administration’s aggressive deportation efforts, including workplace raids and arrests at sensitive locations. The long-term impact—whether reducing fraud or harming public health—remains uncertain.
This marks a significant expansion of the administration’s immigration crackdown, which has already set ambitious targets for arrests. Federal health officials defend the policy as a necessary measure to root out fraudulent Medicaid enrollment. But internal CMS emails reveal deep divisions among staff, with one official accusing leadership of attempting to turn health care administrators into immigration agents.
Under the terms of the deal, ICE can access Medicaid records only on weekdays between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. until Sept. 9 and cannot directly download files. Still, critics argue the mere existence of such an arrangement erodes trust in public health programs.
Federal law already bars undocumented immigrants from standard Medicaid, though emergency care must be provided regardless of legal status. Seven states – California, New York, Illinois, Washington, Oregon, Minnesota and Colorado – have extended additional coverage to some migrants, funding it without federal dollars. The Trump administration, however, has pushed for access to enrollee data from these states, alleging misuse of taxpayer resources.
Privacy issues, legal backlash and internal resistance
Privacy advocates and Democratic lawmakers have sounded alarms, warning that allowing ICE to comb through health care records could have a chilling effect, particularly in states that expanded Medicaid coverage to migrants.
Legal challenges are already mounting, with 20 states suing the federal government over alleged violations of medical privacy laws. California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced plans to seek a court order blocking the data-sharing, arguing that fear of deportation could prevent families from seeking essential medical care. A hearing is scheduled for Aug. 7.
Internal CMS emails obtained bythe Associated Press reveal legal concerns within the agency. One thread, titled “Hold DHS Access — URGENT,” shows attorneys urging a pause on the agreement due to ongoing litigation. Despite these objections, the Department of Justice (DOJ) reportedly approved the data-sharing move.
Congressional Democrats, including Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA), have demanded an immediate halt to the policy, calling it a dangerous overreach that could harm public health.
Yet critics argue the move is part of a broader strategy to intensify deportations. The administration has already increased workplace raids and arrests at sensitive locations like churches and courthouses, fueling fear in immigrant communities.
With legal battles looming and ICE poised to act on the newly accessible data, the long-term implications remain uncertain. Will this deter fraud, as the administration claims? Or will it drive vulnerable populations away from medical care, exacerbating public health risks?
The online safety regulator should use powers to fine social media companies that are not quickly removing racism, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy told Sky News, after concerns were raised by England defender Jess Carter.Carter has declared herself ready to play in the Women's European Championship semi-final against Italy on Tuesday after speaking out on the hate she has faced online during the tournament. Players have expressed frustration they are having […]
Post comments (0)